Episode Recap
WILDER THAN A CAT IN A BATHTUB. The morning after Episode 8, all ten castaways hunted for a new idol — no real idol was found by anyone. In the reward challenge the castaways split into two teams of five. Mike Pinsky captained the purple team (Devin Way, Thien An Nguyen, Lewis Kelly, Eric Macksoud); Sharonda Cox captained the yellow team (Carter Krull, Jelly Loblack, Maggie Nestor, Cristian Chavez). Lewis single-handedly won the slingshot phase for purple, and the winners took a helicopter tour of Fiji plus a beach picnic of fried chicken and chocolate chip cookies.
In the individual immunity challenge — endurance above water, arms-only in the final phase — Carter Krull outlasted Lewis Kelly in a final-two duel of 30+ minutes to win his first individual immunity (+12 under Lever A2). No vote took place. At Tribal Council, Jeff revealed the Million-Dollar Coin Flip: a correct call means safety, an immunity idol, and the prize doubling $1M → $2M; an incorrect call means immediate elimination without a vote. Cristian Chavez, Devin Way, and Lewis Kelly all wanted to flip; Cristian touched the coin, felt "good energy," then backed off, and Devin stepped back for Lewis. Lewis volunteered, called fire ("Maybe I go out with a bang"), the coin landed water — eliminated immediately, torch snuffed, third juror. Rulings are pending on the coin flip and the fake idol.
Meanwhile Devin Way (with Jelly Loblack) had planted a lifelike fake idol in the brush, wrapped in Jelly's old idol paperwork, hoping Maggie Nestor would find it and believe it real. Maggie called it a leaf and refused it; Devin picked it up himself, and Maggie now believes Devin holds a (real) idol. The Salt Alliance (Carter, Lewis, Kilby, Kristin, Thien An, Cristian, Maggie) is fracturing — Cristian told Sharonda about Carter's idol behind Carter's back, and Sharonda is now working with everyone. Jelly and Devin target Maggie as the biggest jury threat; Thien An wants Jelly out; Mike, Eric, and Devin wanted Lewis out as a challenge threat. Nine castaways remain.
Episode Scores by Team
- The league-best week: Carter Krull posted 16 — survival (4) plus his first individual immunity (12 under Lever A2) after a 30+ minute final duel with Lewis Kelly.
- Maggie Nestor added survival (4); she now believes Devin Way holds a real idol.
- Third place holds at 137 — Pre-Merge (Locked) 113, Post-Merge 24. Kacie closes to six points behind second.
- Jelly Loblack scored 4 on survival; her idol is spent and her fake-idol plant with Devin is in play.
- Lewis Kelly scored 1 (reward only) before the Million-Dollar Coin Flip eliminated him — he called fire, the coin landed water, and he is juror No. 3.
- Second place at 143 — Pre-Merge (Locked) 131, Post-Merge 12. Jelly is now Ellynn's only active castaway.
- Thien An Nguyen scored 5 — survival (4) plus the purple team's reward win (1) — and Cristian Chavez added survival (4).
- First place holds at 154 — Pre-Merge (Locked) 122, Post-Merge 32.
- Cristian volunteered for the coin flip, felt "good energy," then backed off — Lewis stepped forward instead.
- Mike Pinsky scored 5 — survival (4) plus the reward win (1) as captain of the winning purple team — and Sharonda Cox added survival (4).
- Fourth place at 113 — Pre-Merge (Locked) 95, Post-Merge 18.
- Sharonda is working with everyone and in no one's crosshairs; Cristian told her about Carter's idol behind Carter's back.
- Devin Way (5) and new pickup Eric Macksoud (5) each banked survival (4) plus the purple team's reward win (1).
- First week with two scoring castaways since the re-draft — Eric's first points for Janet.
- Fifth place at 29 — Pre-Merge (Locked) 25, Post-Merge 4.
Current Standings
| Pos | Team | Captain | Episode | Pre-Merge (Locked) | Post-Merge | Season Total | Movement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Team 3 | Captain JB3 | 9 | 122 | 32 | 154 | held 1st |
| 2 | Team 2 | Ellynn | 5 | 131 | 12 | 143 | held 2nd |
| 3 | Team 1 | Kacie | 20 | 113 | 24 | 137 | held 3rd |
| 4 | Team 4 | Tim | 9 | 95 | 18 | 113 | held 4th |
| 5 | Team 5 | Janet | 10 | 25 | 4 | 29 | held 5th |
Full castaway scoring breakdown (10 players)
| Castaway | Team | Scoring | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carter Krull | Team 1 | 4 survived (A2) + 12 individual immunity win (A2) — first individual immunity | 16 |
| Maggie Nestor | Team 1 | 4 survived (A2) | 4 |
| An “Thien An” Nguyen | Team 3 | 4 survived (A2) + 1 tribal reward (purple team) | 5 |
| Cristian Chavez | Team 3 | 4 survived (A2) | 4 |
| Mike Pinsky | Team 4 | 4 survived (A2) + 1 tribal reward (purple team captain) | 5 |
| Sharonda Cox | Team 4 | 4 survived (A2) | 4 |
| Devin Way | Team 5 | 4 survived (A2) + 1 tribal reward (purple team) | 5 |
| Eric Macksoud | Team 5 | 4 survived (A2) + 1 tribal reward (purple team) | 5 |
| Angelica “Jelly” Loblack | Team 2 | 4 survived (A2) | 4 |
| Lewis Kelly | Team 2 | 1 tribal reward (purple team) — eliminated by the Million-Dollar Coin Flip; no survival scored (O-021) — juror No. 3 | 1 |
League-Wide Data
Beta Tribe Pulse — One Tribe: Tovuto
Merged-tribe split: every Episode 9 point was earned on Tovuto. The reward challenge split the ten castaways into two teams of five; the purple team's five winners each scored +1 (the +4 individual reading is held as open call O-022).
| Team | Tovuto points |
|---|---|
| Team 1 — Kacie | 20 |
| Team 2 — Ellynn | 5 |
| Team 3 — Captain JB3 | 9 |
| Team 4 — Tim | 9 |
| Team 5 — Janet | 10 |
Good Human
Week 8 is CLOSED — no award was reported for Episode 8 moments, so NO AWARD was given. Week 9 nominations — altruistic moments from Episode 9 — are open now. Captains: send nominations to the President by Tuesday, November 24, 2026, at 12:00pm ET; the winner (+2) is revealed that Tuesday before Episode 10.
Episode moment: Lewis Kelly's reward-challenge win carried his whole purple team to the helicopter tour and beach picnic.
League Announcements
- Leftover pool resolved: Janet receives Eric Macksoud and Ellynn received Lewis Kelly, both effective from Episode 9. Eric's first points for Janet landed this week (5); Lewis scored one episode for Ellynn (+1 reward) before the coin flip.
- Hail Mary picks: Still alive: Kacie — Thien An Nguyen; Ellynn — Eric Macksoud; Tim — Devin Way. Janet's pick Ori Jean-Charles was eliminated in Episode 6 — her Hail Mary is dead. Captain JB3 has no pick. A correct Sole Survivor pick banks +8 at season end.
- Advantages now: Carter Krull's idol and Devin Way's extra vote remain unplayed. Devin also holds a fake idol that Maggie Nestor believes is real; Cristian's Extra Vote expired unplayed in Episode 8.
- Trade window is open: Post-merge trades are 1-for-1 (or 2-for-2), balanced only, both captains agree, and the requesting captain pays the fee. Trading closes when a captain loses their last castaway or every captain is down to one. No trades yet this season.
- Ringer lifelines: All five remain available.